Is nuclear energy renewable?

Nuclear energy has produced electricity in America since 1958. But is nuclear energy clean, renewable energy?

A nuclear power plant in Belgium.

In 1951, in Idaho, researchers powered a lightbulb using nuclear energy for the first time, and the American Atomic Energy Age was born. The Atomic Age came to symbolize progress, modernity and the power of science. By 1958, the first commercial nuclear power plant was up and running in Shippingport, Pennsylvania. In just seven years, research took us from powering a lightbulb with nuclear energy, to powering over a hundred thousand homes. 

In 2023, there were 93 operating nuclear reactors in the United States. As concerns over climate change have grown in recent decades, some proponents of nuclear energy characterize it as “clean energy”. The debate over whether nuclear energy is clean, renewable energy often lacks some critical context on how we define what constitutes clean and renewable energy.

What is clean, renewable energy?

While all forms of energy impact our environment, the impacts of some forms of energy are far greater than others.

Truly clean, renewable energy is:

  1. Virtually pollution-free: It produces little to no planet-warming pollution or health-threatening pollution.
  2. Inexhaustible: It comes from natural sources that are regenerative or practically unlimited. No matter how much we use, there will always be more.
  3. Safe: It has minimal impacts on the environment, community safety and public health, and those impacts that do occur are temporary, not permanent.
  4. Efficient: It is a wise use of resources

There are a lot of ways in which nuclear power does not fit these criteria. 

Is nuclear energy renewable?

Take a closer look at the criteria and how nuclear fits into each one:

Nuclear Energy:

Is not virtually pollution free

When we think of pollution, we often think of oil in our oceans or smog in our skies. But there are lots of different kinds of pollution; when it comes to nuclear energy, there are two main ways pollution is created: mining for nuclear fuel and nuclear waste. While nuclear energy does not directly produce greenhouse gas pollution like carbon dioxide or methane, it does produce other pollution that harms humans and our environment. 

Mining nuclear fuel pollutes our environment.

The most common nuclear fuel is uranium. Uranium is a radioactive element that occurs naturally in the earth’s crust. To use it in a nuclear power plant, uranium has to be mined and, like all mining operations, has the potential to pollute the environment. Unlike many mining operations, uranium mines carry the risk of radioactive contamination.

The process of mining uranium unearths other pollutants such as arsenic, mercury, and radioactive uranium itself. From the mining operation, these pollutants can make their way into groundwater and surface water. There are documented cases of pollution in communities as a result of uranium mining. 

Nuclear power plants produce radioactive waste.

Nuclear waste is an unavoidable byproduct of the technology used in today’s nuclear reactors. Just like coal turns to ash, or oil gets burned up, nuclear fuel is depleted over time. Eventually the fuel is used or “spent” to the point it is taken out of the reactor, but it still emits radiation. In fact, spent fuel from nuclear power plants remains radioactive for thousands of years. To date, no safe, long-term storage solution has been found for this waste. While the U.S. has regulations for handling nuclear waste, there are already 90,000 metric tons of it to reckon with in the U.S. alone. That’s about 440 times the weight of the Statue of Liberty. Storage of nuclear waste carries the risk of exposure to radiation for people, plants, wildlife, water supplies, and soils.

Nuclear accidents can spread pollution far and wide.

Major nuclear power incidents like Fukushima and Chernobyl produced a great deal of radioactive pollution contaminating air, soil, and water while taking a toll on human health.

Is not inexhaustible

Nuclear energy does come from natural sources, in the sense that the fuel used in today’s reactors is uranium, a naturally occurring element. But uranium does not regenerate and it is not practically unlimited. For this reason, nuclear energy is not inexhaustible and therefore cannot be renewable. Unlike plentiful, readily available sunlight and wind, nuclear fuel needs to be consistently mined and produced.

Is not safe enough to be considered “safe”

Nuclear energy is not inherently safe. 

Anyone who has visited a nuclear power plant knows that a culture of safety often pervades the plant. As when dealing with any inherently dangerous technologies there are redundancies in safety systems to reduce risk.

Major nuclear power incidents are rare, but devastating when they occur. The most well-known incidents are Three Mile Island, Chernobyl and Fukushima, and there have been numerous other minor accidents and close calls. 

Chernobyl involved an uncontrolled reaction and ultimately resulted in a partial meltdown. Even this partial meltdown caused over 130 cases of acute radiation sickness (ARS) and several radiation-related deaths. Experts predict that the long-term death toll could reach 4,000, as radiation often takes decades to cause cancers and other ailments. 

Fukushima, a 2011 meltdown resulting from a tsunami triggered by a 9.0 magnitude earthquake, had even greater impacts that spread even further. To this day, we have yet to quantify all of the incident’s impacts both locally and globally where winds carried radioactive material. Authorities are still working to clean up radioactive contamination, an effort that is expected to cost $180 billion. When plants fail, whether by way of a full or partial meltdown, it has drastic environmental and human impacts.

The human health impacts of nuclear meltdown are also difficult to quantify; those affected by meltdowns are difficult to track over the long term. Further, those impacts last – both for people and the environment. Those exposed to radiation can pass on genetic mutations to their children and radioactive material continues to be hazardous for thousands of years. It meets none of the criteria to be considered safe.

Is inefficient

Nuclear energy is not financially efficient. On average, the cost of nuclear outpaces both wind and solar energy. We have cheaper and cleaner ways to meet our energy needs than nuclear. Whether that be solar or wind power, nuclear energy is neither cost effective nor the most efficient energy source.

Nuclear energy is not clean, renewable energy

Nuclear waste is often stored underground, but the surrounding area is still dangerous.

Photo by Dan Meyers | Unsplash.com

Uranium has to be mined, and is a finite resource.

Photo by Saskatchewan Schools | Public Domain

Chernobyl Nuclear Power Station had a catastrophic meltdown in 1986. The site is now shrouded in a metal "sarcophagus" to limit further radiation exposure for the surrounding area.

Photo by Vadim Mouchkin, IAEA | CC-BY-SA-2.0

As cumulative generation capacity for wind and solar increases, their costs are trending downwards. The same can not be said for nuclear energy, whose price is trending upwards.

Photo by Our World in Data | CC-BY-4.0

1of 4

Because nuclear energy is not virtually pollution free, inexhaustible, safe, nor efficient, nuclear power can not be considered truly clean, renewable energy. Nuclear energy carries many risks to human and environmental health by way of the pollution it generates, despite the fact that the pollutants resulting from nuclear energy are not of the planet-warming variety. Nuclear energy is not the best use of our resources when we have better, cleaner options available.

What energy sources are clean and renewable?

The cleanest energy is the energy we never use, which is why measures that help reduce energy waste and encourage Americans to conserve energy should be the first fuel we turn to. 

From there, truly renewable energy sources such as wind and solar power are the best energy sources to meet America’s energy needs, delivering virtually pollution-free energy. Both are clean, renewable energy sources that make use of natural resources (sunlight and wind) to produce electricity.

Kindel Media | Used by permission
Solar and wind are two clean, renewable energy sources.

Solar panels and wind turbines are remarkably safe, with no significant risks to human or environmental health when installed responsibly. Finally, solar energy is an efficient use of our resources given that the levelized cost of solar is about half that of nuclear energy. Wind energy, for its part, is by far the most energy efficient power source.

Join One Million for 100% Renewable Energy
Pennsylvanians for Renewable Energy

Clean energy

Join One Million for 100% Renewable Energy

Add your voice and become one of One Million for 100% Renewable Energy to join a growing community of changemakers and take coordinated and strategic action to move our country and our planet to 100 percent.

SIGN UP

Authors

Johanna Neumann

Senior Director, Campaign for 100% Renewable Energy, Environment America Research & Policy Center

Johanna directs strategy and staff for Environment America's energy campaigns at the local, state and national level. In her prior positions, she led the campaign to ban smoking in all Maryland workplaces, helped stop the construction of a new nuclear reactor on the shores of the Chesapeake Bay and helped build the support necessary to pass the EmPOWER Maryland Act, which set a goal of reducing the state’s per capita electricity use by 15 percent. She also currently serves on the board of Community Action Works. Johanna lives in Amherst, Massachusetts, with her family, where she enjoys growing dahlias, biking and the occasional game of goaltimate. 

Caitlin Soch

Campaign for 100% Renewable Energy, Associate, Environment America Research & Policy Center

Caitlin works on Environment America's solar power and energy efficiency campaigns. Caitlin lives in Denver with her Shetland Sheepdog, where she enjoys hiking, paddle boarding and trivia.