How environmentally friendly is your chocolate?

Tropical forests are critical for the planet, but they’re in danger. The rising demand for chocolate has led cocoa farmers to engage in deforestation and unsustainable farming practices.

Forests

Report


Updated

chocolate scorecard | Used by permission

Take Action

Eve Girzadas

Environment America Forests Intern

Americans eat an estimated 12 pounds of chocolate per year per person and we spend $22 billion annually on chocolate.

Some chocolates are better for the planet than others. 

Environment America has joined the Chocolate Scorecard to raise awareness about which chocolate companies are doing their part to limit their impact on our forests and the environment.

 

Cocoa beans are the main ingredient for chocolate.

Chocolate companies responded to a questionnaire and were graded on a set of criteria. We’re highlighting 3 criteria that demonstrate how the cocoa farming operations are affecting the plan.

Learn more about Chocolate Scorecard methodology

1. How growing cocoa beans effects deforestation and climate change  

Tropical forests are hubs of biodiversity. The world’s rainforests hold 50% of all known species, forming rich ecosystems brimming with life from orangutans to tree frogs to poinsettias. Their ability to absorb and store carbon make them essential tools in the efforts to slow climate change. 

Several popular products grown or produced in the tropics, including cacao beans, threaten their existence. Cacao, grown in the tropics of South America, Africa, and Southeast Asia, is a driving force of deforestation in these regions. Typically grown as a monoculture, where cocoa trees are planted over large areas, these rainforests must be cleared to make space for the crops. 

In 2016, Ghana and Côte d’Ivoire produced over half the world’s chocolate supply. From 2001 to 2023, Ghana experienced a 24% loss of its total tree coverage and the Côte d’Ivoire saw a decrease of 26%. With deforestation of this magnitude, the effects of climate change and these forests’ weakened capacity for carbon sequestration threaten not just our chocolate but also wildlife and the environment as a whole. 

Seven products grown or produced in the tropics, including cocoa beans, threaten their existence.

2. What is agroforestry  and how does cocoa bean farming effect it? 

Agroforestry is an agricultural practice that involves planting trees and shrubs in the same plots or fields where crops are growing. This method promotes biodiversity, improves soil quality, enhances resilience to climate change, and often reduces the need for chemicals and pesticides. With these benefits, Agroforestry is sustainable for the people who rely on these crops and the land they use to grow them. 

Agroforestry dates back for generations, but the current standard is to grow monoculture crops where farmers plant trees uniformly over large land areas to produce more cacao in less time. This method strips soil of its nutrients and destroys existing forests to make room for cacao farming, damaging both the natural environment and agricultural fields so that cacao can no longer grow after a few years. Thankfully, the cacao industry is recognizing the problems of  deforestation and biodiversity loss to chocolate production and to the planet as a whole. To become more sustainable, cacao farms are shifting towards agroforestry around the world, rebuilding rainforests to support successful farms and healthy natural habitats. 

3. How are pesticides used in growing cocoa beans?

Monoculture cacao crops are susceptible to pests and disease. To combat this, it is common practice for farmers to use pesticides in growing cacao beans for chocolate. However, Pesticides and Insecticides pose an environmental hazard through runoff contamination of water, soil and air. Pesticides also adversely affect wildlife when overexposed to these chemicals. Pollinators, fish, birds, nearby plants, and whole ecosystems can experience negative impacts from chemical leakages or excessive use. To avoid these harmful effects, sustainable chocolate minimizes pesticides when growing cacao beans. 

Which chocolate brands score highest and where can I find them? 

For a chocolate fix that’s also good for the planet, try these top scorers:

Toney’s Chocoloney

Chocolate scorecard | Used by permission

Of the best-rated brands, Toney’s Chocoloney is unmatched in its sustainability practices. Headquartered in the Netherlands, they rank high across the board for their commitment to transparency, agroforestry, and climate. 

Find it in stores at major retailers or at their online shop

Ritter Sport

Chocolate scorecard | Used by permission

This German brand comes second only to Toney’s when it comes to sustainability. Ritter Sport gets high marks for its environmental practices around forest protection, sustainable farming, and their transparent supply chain. 

Ritter Sport can be found at major retailers and online

Original Beans

Chocolate scorecard | Used by permission

Original Beans is a small brand and the winner of Chocolate Scorecard’s Most Sustainable Chocolate Award 2024. They boast cacao beans grown 100% in regenerative agroforestry, over 15,000 tons of CO2 drawdown through their trees, and exclusive operations in global biodiversity hotspots to support their rehabilitation. 

Though currently only shipping in Europe, you can learn more and order online

How do all the chocolate brands measure up?

Here’s how all of the medium and large commpanies that the Chocolate Scorecard surveyed were scored.

Photo by Staff | Used by permission

To see the scorecards for small companies and retailers, visit the main Chocolate Scorecard.

Topics
Authors

Ellen Montgomery

Director, Public Lands Campaign, Environment America

Ellen runs campaigns to protect America's beautiful places, from local beachfronts to remote mountain peaks. Prior to her current role, Ellen worked as the organizing director for Environment America’s Climate Defenders campaign. Ellen lives in Denver, where she likes to hike in Colorado's mountains.

Eve Girzadas

Environment America Forests Intern

Find Out More